Journal of Sacred Work

Caregivers have superpowers! Radical Loving Care illuminates the divine truth that caregiving is not just a job. It is Sacred Work.

About

Frederick_Douglass_portrait
"I would unite with anybody to do right and nobody to do wrong."  – Frederick Douglass (left)

   America is on the verge of doing something it has never done. If you believe the polls, there is a rising likelihood that this country will elect a President self-identified as African-American. If it happens, it will have taken 232 years for a person "of color" to accomplish such a feat. The very possibility of Barack Obama's election shines a spotlight on America's long history of discrimination.
   Discrimination of any kind interferes with good caregiving. The same spotlight that illuminates Obama's potential triumph also reminds us of the way in which our health care system has, in the past, discriminated against minorities in medical treatment. Most of us know the sad, early history of the treatment of the mentally ill, the disabled, and racial and national minorities not to mention the marginalization of the poor, of rape victims, and of women.
   How can a country grounded in principles of equality have such a history of bias? In one word, the answer is fear. Ignorance no doubt fed this fear. In an effort to accomplish dominance, European-American males have traditionally found "reasons" to achieve control of this country by demeaning others they feared might take control away from them.
James_McCune_Smith
   Why else would women be denied the vote until 1920? Why else would white-run American medical schools refuse to grant admission to James McCune Smith,(left) a brilliant caregiver of the 19th century, driving Smith to a Scottish Medical School. There, Smith received his medical degree and did an internship in Paris before returning to the United States to become America's first black M.D. (in 1837.)
Blackwell_eliz
   It took twelve more years for Elizabeth Blackwell (left) to become America's first female M.D. (in 1849 )Imagine the number of women and other minorities, before and since, who never considered a career as a physician because they feared discrimination!
   This essay is not about the politics of this presidential election. It is about the need for justice in the administration of American healthcare. Prior discrimination in America's professional schools blocked capable people from careers in healthcare. Prior discrimination against patients has caused untold suffering.
   Sadly, discrimination continues to this very day. When anyone of us is weakened by illness or injury we become vulnerable to marginalization by those who are strong. The moment we are reclassified as someone with cancer or AIDS, we are at risk for being condescended to as objects of pity and disdain. How often have you heard some voice in your head telling you that you are "better" than someone who is an alcoholic or who suffers from schizophrenia?
   Why does this matter? Because our attitudes so often affect our behavior. Frederick Douglass offered to "unite with anybody to do right." But, only a small percentage of Americans in Douglass' time could see past his skin color to recognize his genius. What remarkable Presidents Frederick Douglass or Susan B. Anthony would have made. Imagine the medical breakthroughs that might have occurred if the doors of medicine had been opened immediately to all based on ability, not on color or gender or nationality or any other such foolishness.
   Caregiving needs justice. Only Love can guide us to give the same quality of care to a homeless alcoholic that we would want for our mothers. Only Love can provide us with the patience to deal with patients so addled by Alzheimer's that they are unable to remember us from one moment to the next.
   Only Love can enable us to live as true healers. That is why we must always seek to live Love, not fear.

   How do you deal with discrimination and injustice when you see it? How do you encounter the voices within you that may incite you to bias?

-Erie Chapman

Posted in

9 responses to “Days 294-295 – Caregiving & Justice”

  1. ~liz Wessel Avatar
    ~liz Wessel

    I’ve had occasion over the past few months to spend time in two different teaching hospitals in New York. What I found surprising and encouraging is how many women have entered medicine and are becoming physicians. You have shown the many faces that discrimination wears, from the political front where our country remains deeply divided, to those wanting to heal, and to those in need of healing. An ill person, or a grieving person (and family) often dwell on the opposite side of an invisible line alienated by suffering. It is helpful to acknowledge that at the crux of discrimination are fearful thoughts and beliefs and recognize that we can make a conscious of Love over fear.
    I would like to share the following thoughts of physician and poet Rafael Campo. “We’re living through some dangerous times, obsessed with our differences and convinced that strict adherence to some specific belief system—not just science as God, but for others only my God as God, or the self as God, or the dollar as God—will resolve our increasing number of conflicts. I think we need to get away from this idea that we are hopelessly fragmented, that there is no possibility of repair after Auschwitz, or Rwanda. I think we need instead to return to the ancient wisdom that in great works of the imagination lie our best chance to survive as a species, and that in the sum of our diverse stories especially, which are essentially synonymous with our humanity, is the only truth. I want to be helping to tell that truth.”

    Like

  2. Cindy Avatar
    Cindy

    I am a (white) woman who believes in equality for all human race. We were all created equal in God’s eyes and that is all that matters. However…..I do not believe that Barack Obama who is not a God fearing man is the best man for the job. I would vote in a minute for any man of color as long as he is a Bible believing American who I wouldn’t be scared that he will try to take God out of our country. Sorry…….if you want to put Bill Cosby in for our president then I will vote for him. Also…we should never say African American if the person is black or white or hispanic we should all unite and say “American” plain and simple!!!! Just American!!!! Thanks!

    Like

  3. Karen York Avatar
    Karen York

    The most helpful things I can do to return myself to balance when I’m feeling biased is to ask myself these two things:
    1. What am I afraid of?
    2. What is the spirit within me and within you trying to say to each other?
    Love seeks out love in one other.

    Like

  4. Victoria Facey Avatar
    Victoria Facey

    As a black woman, I am happy to learn something new of the history of our first black doctor – as well as the first woman to become a physician. However, in keeping with Erie’s original message:
    “This essay is not about the politics of this presidential election. It is about the need for justice in the administration of American healthcare.” – I’d like us to come back to the lessons to be learned from today’s meditation. Keeping our hearts and minds open when accepting people’s diverse ideas is the real gift.

    Like

  5. Diana Gallaher Avatar
    Diana Gallaher

    As we have noted here at the Journal several times before, it is worth quoting Martin Luther King again on the subject of justice and health care.
    “Of all the forms of inequality, injustice in health care is the most shocking and inhumane.” MLK
    Ageism is another form of discrimination that I have witnessed and, if I am honest, been guilty of, in the health care setting.
    My mother, who is 85, was hospitalized last week. And she received loving care from the hospital staff. Being in the hospital was an exhausting experience, for all of us, my mother in particular (because of IV lines, testing, monitoring, not to mention her illness). I cannot imagine what the experience would have been like if the loving care had been absent.
    My mother was kind and expressed gratitude continuously to the hospital staff, so maybe what Karen says about love seeking out love in one another was occuring.

    Like

  6. ~liz Wessel Avatar
    ~liz Wessel

    It helps me to know that with every thought I have two only two choices to live Love or fear. This truth requires that I become aware and responsible for my thought patterns. To live Love means to share Love. I imagine that after some time the choice becomes automatic and is no longer a choice at all but the only way to live life.

    Like

  7. Rosemary Thomas, R.N. Avatar
    Rosemary Thomas, R.N.

    I pray that all voters will look at ALL that each candidate stands for and NOT just the color of skin!
    Which candidate will protect the rights of all precious souls, including aborted babies born alive that are left to die in an abandoned room without any medical attention?
    Which candidate will help protect the Sanctity of Marriage as is written in the Bible between a man and woman so that our precious children will not be led astray in schools that same sex marriage is a “normal” event instead of one NOT favored by God? (And that is a mild explanation of what God says in the Bible!)
    Those are merely 2 issues alone of what makes our country a Blessed country!
    So I ask what will you vote for, the color of skin, OR issues important that protect our way of life in these United States of America?
    Sincerely,
    Rosemary Thomas, RN

    Like

  8. Rorie Ramirez Avatar
    Rorie Ramirez

    It is unfortunate that only Borack Obama was used in the introduction to this article about discrimination in the health industry. Why not include Sarah Palin somewhere in that framework?God knows women have been discriminated against since time began. Politics should not be used in this discussion.

    Like

  9. Diana Gallaher Avatar
    Diana Gallaher

    I just want to note that University Medical Center in Lebanon, TN is where my mother received loving care by the hospital staff.

    Like

Leave a reply to Rorie Ramirez Cancel reply